• Advertise
  • Opinion
  • Features & Interviews
  • Investigation
  • Contact
Monday, May 16, 2022
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Lagos Today
  • Home
  • News
    • Lagos News
    • National News
    • World News
  • Entertainment⚡ by CRAWL
    • All
    • Art & Design
    • Books
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    Veteran Nigerian Actor, Gbenga Richards Is Dead

    Veteran Nigerian Actor, Gbenga Richards Is Dead

    AGN To Contact Genevieve Nnaji Amid Rumoured Mental Illness

    AGN To Contact Genevieve Nnaji Amid Rumoured Mental Illness

    I Enjoy Inner Peace Being Engaged To Mr Eazi – Temi Otedola

    I Enjoy Inner Peace Being Engaged To Mr Eazi – Temi Otedola

    Legendary Musician, Orlando Julius Dies in the Arms of Wife

    Legendary Musician, Orlando Julius Dies in the Arms of Wife

    Singer, Mr Eazi, Proposes To Femi Otedola’s Daughter, Temi

    Singer, Mr Eazi, Proposes To Femi Otedola’s Daughter, Temi

    WurlD, Lady Donli, Pretty Boy D-O, & More to Headline First Ever Alte Culture Festival in Lagos

    WurlD, Lady Donli, Pretty Boy D-O, & More to Headline First Ever Alte Culture Festival in Lagos

    Cubana Chief Priest Arrested By EFCC Over Fraud Few Weeks After Obi Cubana’s Arrest

    Cubana Chief Priest Arrested By EFCC Over Fraud Few Weeks After Obi Cubana’s Arrest

    FIFA Bans Abuja MKO Abiola Stadium From Hosting Int’l Matches

    FIFA Bans Abuja MKO Abiola Stadium From Hosting Int’l Matches

    BREAKING: Nigeria Crashes Out Of World Cup Qualifier After 1-1 Draw With Ghana

    BREAKING: Nigeria Crashes Out Of World Cup Qualifier After 1-1 Draw With Ghana

    World Cup Playoffs: Super Eagles Hold Black Stars To Goalless Draw

    World Cup Playoffs: Super Eagles Hold Black Stars To Goalless Draw

  • Opinion
  • Business
  • Features & Interviews
  • Best Of Lagos
    Exploring Lagos’ Gastronomy With Chef Priyank Singh of Hard Rock Cafe

    Exploring Lagos’ Gastronomy With Chef Priyank Singh of Hard Rock Cafe

    Olu Oyinsan- Saying Yes To Founders At The Early Stage

    Olu Oyinsan- Saying Yes To Founders At The Early Stage

    A Rare Hobby: Sports Fishing In Lagos

    A Rare Hobby: Sports Fishing In Lagos

    Chef Nkesi- Experiencing Different Cultures Through Food

    Chef Nkesi- Experiencing Different Cultures Through Food

    Wumi Jubril: Creating Memorable Experiences

    Wumi Jubril: Creating Memorable Experiences

    Nordic hotel

    Nordic Hotel Makes Grand Debut in Lagos

    Bookstores in Lagos

    Love Reading? See The Best Bookstores In Lagos

    Event Centre

    Event Centres in Lagos

    Lounges and bars in Lagos? Here are five exciting spots to try out

    Lounges and bars in Lagos? Here are five exciting spots to try out

  • Things To Do
  • Home
  • News
    • Lagos News
    • National News
    • World News
  • Entertainment⚡ by CRAWL
    • All
    • Art & Design
    • Books
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    Veteran Nigerian Actor, Gbenga Richards Is Dead

    Veteran Nigerian Actor, Gbenga Richards Is Dead

    AGN To Contact Genevieve Nnaji Amid Rumoured Mental Illness

    AGN To Contact Genevieve Nnaji Amid Rumoured Mental Illness

    I Enjoy Inner Peace Being Engaged To Mr Eazi – Temi Otedola

    I Enjoy Inner Peace Being Engaged To Mr Eazi – Temi Otedola

    Legendary Musician, Orlando Julius Dies in the Arms of Wife

    Legendary Musician, Orlando Julius Dies in the Arms of Wife

    Singer, Mr Eazi, Proposes To Femi Otedola’s Daughter, Temi

    Singer, Mr Eazi, Proposes To Femi Otedola’s Daughter, Temi

    WurlD, Lady Donli, Pretty Boy D-O, & More to Headline First Ever Alte Culture Festival in Lagos

    WurlD, Lady Donli, Pretty Boy D-O, & More to Headline First Ever Alte Culture Festival in Lagos

    Cubana Chief Priest Arrested By EFCC Over Fraud Few Weeks After Obi Cubana’s Arrest

    Cubana Chief Priest Arrested By EFCC Over Fraud Few Weeks After Obi Cubana’s Arrest

    FIFA Bans Abuja MKO Abiola Stadium From Hosting Int’l Matches

    FIFA Bans Abuja MKO Abiola Stadium From Hosting Int’l Matches

    BREAKING: Nigeria Crashes Out Of World Cup Qualifier After 1-1 Draw With Ghana

    BREAKING: Nigeria Crashes Out Of World Cup Qualifier After 1-1 Draw With Ghana

    World Cup Playoffs: Super Eagles Hold Black Stars To Goalless Draw

    World Cup Playoffs: Super Eagles Hold Black Stars To Goalless Draw

  • Opinion
  • Business
  • Features & Interviews
  • Best Of Lagos
    Exploring Lagos’ Gastronomy With Chef Priyank Singh of Hard Rock Cafe

    Exploring Lagos’ Gastronomy With Chef Priyank Singh of Hard Rock Cafe

    Olu Oyinsan- Saying Yes To Founders At The Early Stage

    Olu Oyinsan- Saying Yes To Founders At The Early Stage

    A Rare Hobby: Sports Fishing In Lagos

    A Rare Hobby: Sports Fishing In Lagos

    Chef Nkesi- Experiencing Different Cultures Through Food

    Chef Nkesi- Experiencing Different Cultures Through Food

    Wumi Jubril: Creating Memorable Experiences

    Wumi Jubril: Creating Memorable Experiences

    Nordic hotel

    Nordic Hotel Makes Grand Debut in Lagos

    Bookstores in Lagos

    Love Reading? See The Best Bookstores In Lagos

    Event Centre

    Event Centres in Lagos

    Lounges and bars in Lagos? Here are five exciting spots to try out

    Lounges and bars in Lagos? Here are five exciting spots to try out

  • Things To Do
No Result
View All Result
The Lagos Today
No Result
View All Result
Home Tech

Trump Suits Against Tech Giants Face Steep First Amendment Hurdles

by The Lagos Today
July 12, 2021
in Tech
5 min read
0
0
House impeachment managers request former President Donald Trump testify at trial
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Whatever else might be said about the curious lawsuits filed last week by former President Donald J. Trump, in which he accused three big tech companies of violating his First Amendment rights by denying him access to their platforms, it is fitting that he sued in Florida.

The state has long been on the cutting edge, and on the losing end, of efforts to force private companies to publish political messages to which they object.

Almost 50 years ago, the Supreme Court struck down a Florida law that would have allowed politicians a “right to reply” to newspaper articles critical of them. And late last month, a federal judge in Florida blocked a new state law that would have imposed large fines on some tech companies (but not those that own theme parks in the state, like Disney) that “willfully deplatform a candidate for office.”

Together, the two decisions, one from the Nixon era and the other issued on June 30, demonstrate that the lawsuits Mr. Trump filed in Miami on Wednesday against Facebook, Twitter and YouTube face steep odds. The First Amendment applies to government censorship and not private activities, courts have said, and it protects publishers’ editorial judgments, including ones that decline to give politicians a forum.

The case that gave rise to the 1974 Supreme Court decision was brought by Pat L. Tornillo, who was displeased by colorful editorials in The Miami Herald opposing his candidacy for the Florida House of Representatives. The newspaper said Mr. Tornillo, a labor union official, had engaged in “shakedown statesmanship.”

Mr. Tornillo invoked a Florida law that required newspapers to give candidates they criticized free space for a reply “in as conspicuous a place and in the same kind of type.” The newspaper refused, lost in the state’s highest court and appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Mr. Tornillo and his supporters said, in Chief Justice Warren E. Burger’s summary, that “a communications revolution” and “the specter of a ‘wired’ nation” justified the law, as did “the vast accumulations of unreviewable power in the modern media empires.”

All of that may be so, Chief Justice Burger wrote for a unanimous court. But the First Amendment, he wrote, does not permit the government to usurp the role of editors in deciding what ought to be published.

“A responsible press is an undoubtedly desirable goal,” he wrote, “but press responsibility is not mandated by the Constitution, and like many other virtues it cannot be legislated.”

Justice Byron R. White, who was often hostile to the news media, wrote in a concurring opinion that an unregulated and unruly press is better than the alternative of government control.

“Of course, the press is not always accurate, or even responsible, and may not present full and fair debate on important public issues,” he wrote. “But the balance struck by the First Amendment with respect to the press is that society must take the risk that occasionally debate on vital matters will not be comprehensive and that all viewpoints may not be expressed.”

Less than two weeks ago, Judge Robert L. Hinkle of the Federal District Court in Tallahassee blocked another Florida law, this one enacted in May and animated by some of the same ideas rejected by the Supreme Court in 1974. The law would impose fines on some social media platforms for exercising editorial judgments in declining to amplify the views of politicians who ran afoul of their standards.

In a statement issued when he signed the bill, Gov. Ron DeSantis, a Republican, said the point of the law was to promote conservative viewpoints. “If Big Tech censors enforce rules inconsistently, to discriminate in favor of the dominant Silicon Valley ideology, they will now be held accountable,” he said.

Judge Hinkle cited the Tornillo decision but wrote that there are significant differences between newspapers and platforms like Facebook and Twitter.

“Newspapers, unlike social media providers,” he wrote, “create or select all their content, including op-eds and letters to the editor,” he wrote. By contrast, he wrote, “something well north of 99 percent of the content that makes it onto a social media site never gets reviewed further.”

But the new law, Judge Hinkle wrote, was aimed at “ideologically sensitive cases,” ones in which the platforms used discretion much as newspapers do.

“Those are the very cases on which the platforms are most likely to exercise editorial judgment,” he wrote. “Indeed, the targets of the statutes at issue are the editorial judgments themselves.”

Perhaps the oddest part of the law was its exclusion of social media providers under common ownership with large theme parks. That discrimination, an apparent favor to powerful local businesses, was reason enough to subject the law to the most demanding form of constitutional scrutiny, Judge Hinkle wrote.

Mr. DeSantis has said the state will appeal, and there is at least one member of the Supreme Court who seems open to considering whether new technologies require new rules. In April, Justice Clarence Thomas issued a concurring opinion when the court turned down a case on whether Mr. Trump had violated the First Amendment by blocking people from his Twitter account, saying it was moot.

Justice Thomas used the occasion to muse on a larger question, one pertinent to both the Florida law and Mr. Trump’s lawsuits.

“Today’s digital platforms provide avenues for historically unprecedented amounts of speech, including speech by government actors,” he wrote. “Also unprecedented, however, is the concentrated control of so much speech in the hands of a few private parties. We will soon have no choice but to address how our legal doctrines apply to highly concentrated, privately owned information infrastructure such as digital platforms.”

–NEW YORK TIMES

Follow us on social media
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...
Tags: Donald TrumpTECH
Previous Post

Covid-19: National Assembly Okays N4.87bn For Tracking Calls, Messages

Next Post

Jacob Zuma: Military deployed to tackle unrest over jailed ex-president

The Lagos Today

The Lagos Today

Related Posts

MTN Plan Early Deployment Of 5G, Target H2 2022

MTN Plan Early Deployment Of 5G, Target H2 2022

by Idonosan Debe
April 28, 2022
0

Nigerians may begin to enjoy 5G services soon as MTN Nigeria plans an early launch of the technology. According to...

Elon Musk overtakes Bezos to become world’s richest person

Nigeria, Twitter Agreement Suffers Setback As Musk Buys Microblogging Platform

by Rosemary Opara
April 26, 2022
0

There are indications that Twitter’s agreement with the Nigerian government will be reviewed in the months as Elon Musk sealed...

Next Post
Jacob Zuma: Military deployed to tackle unrest over jailed ex-president

Jacob Zuma: Military deployed to tackle unrest over jailed ex-president

Please login to join discussion

Recommended

Oil Prices Hit $60 per Barrel as Iraq, Kazakhstan Slashes Output

Nigeria To Raise Oil Production By 2m Barrels

11 months ago
Nigerian Firm To Complete Rice Mill Expansion in Kebbi Before 2024

Nigerian Firm To Complete Rice Mill Expansion in Kebbi Before 2024

4 months ago

Popular News

    Newsletter

    Connect with us

    Tags

    #EndSARS #EndSARS Protests 2023 Elections 2023 polls 2023 Presidency ACCIDENT APC Babajide Sanwo-Olu Bitcoin CBN Central Bank of NIgeria China Coronavirus pandemic Covid-19 Covid-19 in Lagos Covid-19 in Nigeria Covid-19 Vaccine Covid-19 Worldwide Cryptocurrency Donald Trump Dubai EFCC Federal Government Federal Government of Nigeria Fraud Gov. Sanwo-Olu Insecurity Lagos state Lagos State Government Lagos State Police command LASEMA Latest jobs in lagos Lekki Lekki Tollgate Shooting Muhammadu Buhari Murder NDLEA Nigeria Rape Russia SARS Strike action UK United states US

    News

    • Business
    • National
    • Politics
    • Tech

    Opinion

    • Editorials
    • Today’s Opinion
    • Letters
    • Sunday Review
    • Advertise
    • Opinion
    • Features & Interviews
    • Investigation
    • Contact

    © 2020 The Lagos Today - Nkali.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
      • Lagos News
      • National News
      • World News
    • Entertainment
    • Opinion
    • Business
    • Features & Interviews
    • Best Of Lagos
    • Things To Do

    © 2020 The Lagos Today - Nkali.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Create New Account!

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In
    %d bloggers like this: